The Dutton family, battered but unbowed, facing a brutal Montana winter and enemies creeping closer by the day. If that doesn’t hook you, what will? Season 2 of 1923—the gripping Yellowstone prequel—drops on Paramount+ this Sunday, February 23, 2025, and it’s the last chance to see these iconic characters fight for their legacy. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or just jumping into the Dutton saga, this cast and character guide has everything you need to know about who’s who, what’s at stake, and why you won’t want to miss a second of the drama.
The stakes are higher than ever as Jacob and Cara Dutton battle rivals, weather, and economic ruin to protect their sprawling Yellowstone Dutton Ranch. Meanwhile, Spencer and Alexandra’s love story unfolds across continents, and new faces stir the pot in Paradise Valley. Ready to dive in? Let’s meet the stars bringing this epic tale to life—and stick around for a teaser that’ll have you counting down to the premiere.
The Dutton Family: The Heart of 1923 Season 2
The Duttons are no strangers to hardship, but Season 2 pushes them to their limits. Here’s who’s leading the charge—and who’s fighting to survive.
Harrison Ford as Jacob Dutton: The Patriarch Under Fire
Ever wondered what it takes to hold a family empire together when the world’s falling apart? Harrison Ford’s Jacob Dutton knows all too well. As the older brother of 1883’s James Dutton, Jacob steps up after tragedy strikes, turning a modest 160-acre homestead into a jaw-dropping 780,000-acre ranch. But with the Great Depression hitting early and ruthless rivals circling, Jacob’s legacy hangs by a thread. Ford—yep, the Indiana Jones and Han Solo—brings gritty resolve to this role, fresh off his Marvel debut as Red Hulk in Captain America: Brave New World. Talk about range!
Helen Mirren as Cara Dutton: The Fierce Matriarch
Helen Mirren’s Cara Dutton is the glue holding the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch together—and she’s not messing around. This Irish-born powerhouse runs the show alongside Jacob, juggling family chaos and Prohibition-era challenges with steely grace. Mirren, an Oscar winner for The Queen and a ‘90s icon from Prime Suspect, proves she’s still got it. Rumor has it she’s eyeing a role in Anton Corbijn’s Switzerland next—can this legend get any cooler?
Brandon Sklenar as Spencer Dutton: The War-Torn Wanderer
Spencer Dutton, played by Brandon Sklenar, is the wild card of the family. The younger son of James and Margaret, he’s back from the American Expedition Force carrying scars deeper than any battlefield wound. Instead of rushing home, he’s hunting in Namibia, searching for purpose—until duty calls him back to Montana. Sklenar’s star is rising fast after It Ends With Us, and his brooding intensity makes Spencer’s journey unmissable.
Julia Schlaepfer as Alexandra Dutton: The Countess Turned Rebel
From British royalty to Dutton chaos, Julia Schlaepfer’s Alexandra is living a love story for the ages. This ex-countess ditches etiquette for passion when she meets Spencer in Kenya, and their elopement sets off a cross-continental quest to reunite. Schlaepfer, known from The Politician, lights up the screen with her fierce determination. Will she make it back to Montana? You’ll have to watch to find out.
The Romantic Rancher
Darren Mann’s Jack Dutton is all heart—split between his love for the ranch and his fiancée, Elizabeth Strafford. As Jacob’s great-nephew, he’s got big boots to fill, but Mann (Chilling Adventures of Sabrina) makes Jack’s quiet strength and vulnerability shine. Will love or duty win out? Season 2’s got the answers.
Michelle Randolph as Elizabeth Strafford: The Bride-to-Be in Crisis
Michelle Randolph’s Elizabeth Strafford thought she’d found her happily-ever-after with Jack—until a miscarriage rocked her world. As Bob Strafford’s daughter, she’s caught in the Dutton orbit, and Randolph (Landman) brings raw emotion to every scene. Her story’s a rollercoaster you won’t want to miss.
The Rivals and Wild Cards: Trouble in Paradise Valley
The Duttons aren’t the only ones making waves. These characters bring tension, betrayal, and plenty of surprises to 1923 Season 2.
Jerome Flynn as Banner Creighton: The Sheep Farmer’s Revenge
Jerome Flynn’s Banner Creighton is a Scottish sheep farmer with a grudge—and he’s ready to burn the Duttons’ world down. Season 2 cranks their rivalry to 11, and Flynn (Game of Thrones’ Bronn) delivers a villain you’ll love to hate. Expect fireworks.
Timothy Dalton as Donald Whitfield: The Ruthless Mastermind
Timothy Dalton’s Donald Whitfield is the ultimate bad guy, eyeing Paradise Valley with zero remorse. This former James Bond (The Living Daylights) channels that 007 charisma into a chilling performance. Can the Duttons stop him? It’s a showdown you can’t look away from.
Brian Geraghty as Zane Davis: The Loyal Foreman on the Run
Brian Geraghty’s Zane Davis is the ranch foreman you’d want in your corner—loyal to the Duttons but dodging the law after Season 1’s chaos. Known for The Hurt Locker and Chicago P.D., Geraghty keeps you guessing about Zane’s next move.
Aminah Nieves as Teonna Rainwater: The Fighter Rising Up
Aminah Nieves’ Teonna Rainwater is a force of nature. Stripped of her land and trapped in an abusive Catholic boarding school, this Broken Rock Reservation native isn’t backing down. Nieves (Blueberry) makes Teonna’s resilience unforgettable.
Sebastian Roché as Father Renaud: The Corrupt Priest
Sebastian Roché’s Father Renaud is a priest you wouldn’t trust with your soul. Running his boarding school with a cruel hand, he’s got Teonna in his crosshairs. Roché (Odyssey 5) oozes menace in every scene.
Jennifer Carpenter as Mamie Fossett: The Law in Chaos
Jennifer Carpenter’s Mamie Fossett is a U.S. deputy marshal keeping order—or trying to—in a lawless land. Fresh off Dexter, Carpenter’s intensity makes Mamie a standout. Warrants, arrests, and Dutton drama? She’s in the thick of it.
Augustus Prew as Paul: The Stylish Stranger
Augustus Prew’s Paul is a dapper Brit aboard a passenger ship, adding a dash of mystery to the mix. With credits like Prison Break, Prew’s flair makes Paul a quirky highlight.
Janet Montgomery as Hillary: The Justice Seeker
Janet Montgomery’s Hillary is all about setting things right, and she’s not afraid to get her hands dirty. Known for Salem, Montgomery brings fierce energy to this enigmatic role.
Why You Can’t Miss 1923 Season 2
Still on the fence? 1923 Season 2 isn’t just another chapter—it’s the Duttons’ last stand. With a cast this stacked, a story this intense, and a premiere just days away (February 23, 2025, on Paramount+), there’s no excuse to sit it out. From Jacob and Cara’s desperate fight to Spencer and Alexandra’s globe-spanning romance, every moment’s packed with stakes that hit hard.
Your Next Step: Get Ready for the Premiere
Don’t get left behind—catch up on Season 1, mark your calendar, and join the Duttons for their final ride. Want more 1923 scoop? Drop your thoughts in the comments or share this guide with your fellow fans. Let’s ride into Season 2 together—see you on Sunday!